Posted in Hiking

GPS Mapping Apps: MyTrails – a Replacement for Google MyTracks

One feature we often include with our articles is a map of our hike. Originally we used a handheld Magellan Explorist 310 to do the job of mapping our hike. But as we acquired more capable smart phones, we’d switched over to Google’s MyTracks application for Android phones. This app had a bit of a learning curve and some idiosyncrasies, but we became accustomed to it and it became our goto application for mapping. We used it for finding our way on the trail (or back to our car) and afterwards to view distance traveled and total elevation gain. For our web site, we could either do a screen capture from our phone or easily export the data to Google Maps (web app) and then embed the Google Map web page in our site.

MyTracks Map – GPS trace of our 8.4 mile October 31, 2015 hike at Shawnee State Forest

All was good until a few weeks ago, we fired up MyTracks for a hike and it informed us that Google was discontinuing it and it would stop working on April 30, 2016!





Good-bye MyTracks!

We could always go back to using the handheld Magellen. However, I’d gotten used to using my phone for hiking and the GPS chip in my latest phone was more accurate and got satellite lock a lot faster than the older Magellen unit. I tried a variety of GPS apps from the Android store and settled on an app called MyTrails. Here’s what I like about it:

  • Lots of customizable preferences
  • Variety of free map sources including Microsoft and Google maps (including terrain and satellite maps), OSM (open source) maps, and my favorite: USGS 7.5′ Topo Maps
  • Can be set to omit ‘pauses’ from map – stopping to take photos, etc.
  • Summary pages of details and statistics from hike
  • Elevation graphs of the hike
  • Can screen capture images, or export GPX files
  • The capability of storing off-line maps for use in areas with no cell signal

And a few things I don’t like:

  • LOTS of customizable preferences
  • MyTracks audibly announced distance and speed every mile, MyTrails doesn’t do this
  • Can export to Google Maps, but not as easily
  • MyTracks displayed calories burned, MyTrails doesn’t
MyTrails: 4.1 mile hike on March 12, 2016 at Shawnee State Forest
MyTrails: Details of Shawnee Hike
MyTrails: Elevation graph for Shawnee Hike
My Trails: Recording Preferences – one of the several options screens

The MyTrails app is published by FrogSparks and is available from the Google Play Store. There is a free version (with advertising) and a paid version (which I purchased) that costs $2.38.

Project Fi

Deb and I recently replaced our aging Android phones with Nexus 5X phones. The Nexus 5x as well as it’s big brother the Nexus 6P phone support Google’s Project Fi. Project Fi is Google’s entry into the market as a wireless provider. We signed up for Project Fi (replacing our previous Sprint service). The cost is $20 / month for unlimited voice / text plus a rate of $10 / GB (rounded to the nearest MB) for cellular data plus tax. There is no charge for data over WiFi. Google has cut a deal with Sprint and T-Mobile to use both networks. If the phone is connected to WiFi, it will use that for data and phone calls (both voice and text). If WiFi is not available, the phone will look for the fastest and strongest Sprint or T-Mobile signal. It may change providers several times during the course of the day.

I’ve had the service since January and Deb’s had it for several weeks. Having access to two networks has been handy and we’ve gotten access to more LTE (fast) networks than we had with Sprint alone. However there are still dead spots in Ohio where neither network has coverage. One is at Malabar Farm State Park. A large dead zone is Shawnee State Forest and Shawnee State Park. We stayed at a cabin at Shawnee and had no cell signal. However, because the lodge and the cabins have WiFi, we had access to both data and text / voice calling during our stay. We’ve got the phones set to acquire most data over WiFi (books, podcasts, maps, news). Thus, so far our costs for cell service are lower.




Additional information
© Deborah Platt, Robert Platt and TrekOhio.com 2012 to 2017


2 thoughts on “GPS Mapping Apps: MyTrails – a Replacement for Google MyTracks

  1. Thanks for this post. I have been looking into getting a handheld GPS, and was not really sure where to start my research. As an avid reader of your site, I remembered that you guys put gps maps on your posts, so I thought to myself, “I wonder what Robert and Deb do?” I do have a question though. I am assuming, that if you want to map your trek as you go, you would have to be in a spot with data service, correct? In other words, you would have to have data service in order to use the app, unless you are pulling up a saved map, correct? And do you REALLY prefer this app over a handheld gps? Thanks for help!

    1. Good questions. You do not need data service to record a GPS trace. In fact we often turn on ‘Airplance Mode’ in no signal / weak signal areas to reduce phone battery usage, while enabling GPS to record a trace. The map layer is separate from the recording – if you haven’t pre-loaded a map or have data service, there will be no map layer while you record (it CAN be added after the fact). I usually pre-load a topo map.

      Newer GPS chips get satellite lock much faster than old units. I recall standing around for several minutes waiting for lock with older units. So I like using my new phone much better than my old handheld GPS unit. But that’s mostly due to the newer GPS chip.

Leave a Reply

You have to agree to the comment policy.

Complete the following sentence by typing either real or spam:
My comment is ...